Interview: Murray, “An Ornament to His Country”

20 04 2024

Published in 2023, An Ornament to His Country: The Life and Military Career of Benjamin Franklin Davis, is a biography of the man perhaps best known for leading the breakout of his cavalry from Harper’s Ferry on the eve of the Battle of Antietam. The author discusses her project below:

—————

BR: Can you tell us a little bit about yourself?

SAM: I am a native Idahoan, with degrees in history and mining engineering from the University of Idaho. While completing graduate work I wrote two theses, The Marshall Lake Mines: Their History and Development (1979) and A Preliminary Economic Evaluation of the Golden Anchor Mine (1984). I have also had at least eight articles on Idaho mining history published in magazines including the International California Mining Journal and Idaho Yesterday. I worked in both surface and underground precious metal mines and spent almost 20 years managing leasing and mined land reclamation programs for the Idaho Department of Lands before retiring in 2009. In 2010 I moved east to volunteer at Antietam National Battlefield. Four years later I became a national park service certified battlefield guide at Antietam.

BR: What got you interested in the Civil War?

SAM: I became interested in the Civil War in college and began studying the war in earnest and traveling to battlefields in 2003. I initially focused on the Western Theatre but after moving east concentrated on the Eastern Theatre. I have always been interested in the life histories and careers of the men who fought in the war.

BR: So, why Grimes Davis?

SAM: I first became interested in Grimes Davis while researching a program I offered to present for a summer lecture series in Sharpsburg, Maryland about the exodus of the cavalry from Harpers Ferry on September 14, 1862. Davis appeared to have been one of the most significant figures in the drama but there was minimal information about him in published source, so I started digging. With perseverance, hard work, and encouragement from the late Ted Alexander I finally dredged up enough information about him, predominately from primary sources, to write his biography.

BR: I think the easiest way to begin discussing your new book is to start with the title: “An Ornament to His Country.“ What’s the story behind that?

SAM: When Davis was seeking an appointment to the United State Military Academy in 1849 his friends and supporters referred to him as having the potential to be “An Ornament to His Country.” In June 1863 when his commanding officer Brigadier General John Buford, mentioned his mortal wounding at Brandy Station, Buford noted in his official report Davis was “An Ornament to His Country” and “a bright star in his profession.”

BR: So, who was Benjamin Franklin Davis, and why is he called “Grimes”?

SAM: Benjamin Franklin Davis, who was born in Alabama in 1831, and raised in Louisiana and Mississippi, was a Mexican War veteran at age 16, a West Point graduate (1854) and a career United States Army officer, who served with distinction in the First U.S. Dragoons (renamed the First U. S. Cavalry in August 1861), the First California Volunteer Cavalry Battalion and the Eighth New York Volunteer Cavalry. He was mortally wounded soon after leading the brigade he commanded across the Rappahannock at Beverley’s Ford at dawn on June 9, 1863, during the opening hours of the Battle of Brandy Station. He is buried at the West Point Cemetery. He was nicknamed “Grimes” or “Old Grimes” by fellow cadets at West Point (1850-1854). I have been unable to ascertain where the nickname came from, however.

BR: What were the most surprising things you turned up during the process? Did anything conflict with or confirm your preconceived notions? What were the major stumbling blocks you had to overcome?

SAM: I was surprised and delighted to find the names of his parents and various maternal relatives, his birth date, and that he had five younger brothers and two younger half-brothers. Three of his younger brothers served with Mississippi infantry regiments in the Civil War. Two of them were regimental color bearers. One brother, who was wounded twice and captured twice, was the only one to survive the war. I was also surprised to find out that he was one of four Captains of Cadets at West Point in 1854 (his firstie year), and how highly he was regarded by superior officers, those under his command, and fellow officers who served with him during the Civil War. I did not really have any preconceived notions about Davis because there was such little information about him in published sources that it was impossible to form an opinion. When I started the research, I never thought I would find enough material about his life and career to write a short article let alone a book. One thing led to another and after going down a lot of rabbit holes and verifying information from some sources for accuracy I was finally able to piece together his life story. It is a story worth telling of a very accomplished, courageous, gallant, gentlemanly young American who deserves to be remembered.

BR: Can you describe your research and writing process? What online and brick and mortar sources did you rely on most? How did technology, the easier availability of source materials like newspapers and digitized archives, affect how you went about it?

SAM: I completed the majority of the research before I commenced writing the book however I would periodically continue my research while writing as additional resources are often posted to online sites. Once I started writing I focused on describing Davis’s life chronologically from birth until his untimely death. When I found new material, I would weave it into the narrative where appropriate. Most of the research was done online. Digitized archives, books, family trees, and records available predominately on Google Books, Ancestry.com, Fold3.com and Newspapers.com were invaluable as were digitized records from the United States Military Academy Library and the National Archives. Staff at the West Point Library were kind enough to email me several sets of records specific to Davis’s time at the academy and his burial. The book probably never would have been written without the information that is available online with the click of a mouse because there is too little information available in brick and mortar sources.

BR: How has the book been received?

SAM: The book has been well received by those who have purchased it either from me or from online sources. It is now available at the bookstore at Antietam National Battlefield and hopefully will soon be available at Harpers Ferry National Historical Park.

BR: What’s next for you?

SAM: I am working on updating the draft of a book I completed many years ago but never published about the history of dredge mining in Idaho. I might also work on a biography of another distinguished cavalry officer Thomas Casimer Devin.





Central Ohio Civil War Roundtable, 4/10/2024

11 04 2024
I forgot to take the selfie at the beginning of the meeting. I grabbed this one as everyone headed out afterwards.
You can glimpse the USMC pre-anchor/globe/eagle through the period correct canopy jungle.
Me in action courtesy of Roundtablian Tim Maurice

About 25-30 folks showed up for my presentation to the Central Ohio Civil War Roundtable last night. It was a good time, and the first time talking about the U. S. Marines at First Bull Run. I think it went pretty well but hit my first captioning mistake on the second slide! Good questions afterward, and I fit the whole thing including Q&A in an hour. That’s a first. The nature of the questions is pushing me into developing a program covering all of the action, though that really limits the opportunity for the discussion of people, and that’s more my bag. Let me know in the comments if you’d like me to come and talk to your group on this or any of the others I’ve covered, or if you have a custom program you’d like me to prepare.

With Roundtablian Mike Peters and his grandson Aedyn.




Bull Run Civil War Round Table, 1/11/2024

15 01 2024

This past Thursday evening I presented In the Footsteps of the 69th New York State Militia to 48 real live members of the Bull Run Civil War Round Table in Centreville, VA (there were more on Zoom and Facebook Live). Again, the program ran long (you can view it via a link on the round table’s Facebook page), but nobody left – at least, not that I noticed. The best part was that a good number of friends showed up. From the Manassas National Battlefield Park were rangers Jim Burgess, Greg Wolf, and Anthony Trusso; from the American Battlefield Trust Melissa Winn (thanks for the great photos); from Prince William County Rob Orrison; authors Gene Schmiel and Frank Simione; and educator Dave Kinsella. Thanks to president Kim Brace and past president Mark Whitenton. You have a knowledgeable and welcoming group.

Photo courtesy of Melissa Winn
I honestly can’t recall who took this photo of Melissa Winn, Anthony Trusso, and me, but it was on Melissa’s camera

A few Civil War markers outside the Centreville Regional Library, the venue:

A fine Melissa Winn photo with my new National Museum of Civil War Medicine hat courtesy of Dana Shoaf




Interview: Vignola, “Contrasts in Command”

6 01 2024
Author Victor Vignola at the Adams House on the Fair Oaks battlefield.

Victor Vignola’s Contrasts in Command: The Battle of Fair Oaks, May 31-June 1, 1862 is a 2023 release from Savas Beatie. Vic has kindly taken some time to answer a few questions about this new book (254 pp).

—————

BR: Can you tell us a little bit about yourself?

VV: I am a lifelong student of American History. Over time, the study of the Civil War has grown into my passion, which my wife and sons appreciate since it means my time is occupied. I worked for the New York State Office of Mental Health (OMH) for forty-six years. Much of the time spent in labor relations as a representative of OMH senior management often representing OMH in hearings and at inter-agency levels. In addition, I was recognized for a project conducted with the National Institute of Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) for my expertise in the development of OMH policy and training initiatives geared toward reducing the occurrence of client on staff workplace violence.

As you can see, my professional career had little to do with my recent endeavors. My introduction to conducting research and writing first occurred in the early 2000’s when I wrote of a Union soldier from Orange County, New York. The story of Hiram Willis appeared in the Orange County Historical Society Magazine in 2010. Contrasts in Command is my first book. In October 2022, North & South magazine published a short article summarizing the Battle of Fair Oaks based upon my work. This January, the America’s Civil War magazine will publish an article titled Very Convenient Truth which describes how James Longstreet and Joseph Johnston conspired to scapegoat Benjamin Huger for their failures during the Battle of Seven Pines.

Since the journey of writing Contrasts in Command began, the most significant achievement has been the American Battlefield Trust’s acquisition of the nearly twelve acres of property at the Adams House location on the Fair Oaks battlefield. The acquisition of this property is significant as it is the only parcel of preserved ground on the entire Seven Pines (Fair Oaks) battlefield. The stars aligned to bring the property owner, my research, and the resources of the Trust together to make the preservation possible.

BR: What got you interested in the Civil War?

VV: There’s no singular event or book that piqued my interest. I developed an early interest in reading stories about the Revolutionary and Civil Wars while growing up on and near farms in New York. Even then, my focus centered around my attempt at trying to understand how the fighting unfolded. This included my study of available maps while envisioning how the battle scenes might have developed. Eventually, I discovered the Time/Life Pictorial books and Bruce Catton’s books, which fed my zeal to understand even more. Of course, after I made my first trip to Gettysburg I was hooked for life. Now I am happiest when I am on a field, any field, with books and maps on hand.

BR: Why did you decide to focus on The Battle of Fair Oaks?

VV: The short answer: the Battle of Fair Oaks made the decision for me.

The writing of this book was quite accidental as I had no intention of writing anything until I began digging into the story of the struggle for the Adams House. Over the years, Charlie Fennel – a good friend and an emeritus Gettysburg LBG – and I have conducted tours at various Civil War locations. Our 2019 tour focused on delivering an in-depth field study of the Seven Days battles. As prep for describing events which led to the Seven Days, what battle would be a better place to start than … Seven Pines?

During one of our scouting trips, I asked Bobby Krick about the Adams House and if the house still existed. Bobby informed me of the location and from his information I wrote a letter to the property owner asking permission to research her property and to bring our small tour group there. After gathering more information regarding the struggle at Fair Oaks and the Adams House, I was hooked.

The story is an amazing one that had previously never been told with any depth. Freeman, Dowdey, Sears, and Newton each wrote accounts which focused more on the Seven Pines sector of the fight and of James Longstreet’s alleged misunderstanding of his orders. All that had been written about Fair Oaks was Sumner’s brave soldiers crossing the flooded Chickahominy River and Johnston’s wounding which then led to Robert E. Lee’s appointment to command of the Army of Northern Virginia.

Johnston’s wounding at Fair Oaks pretty much summed up all I knew of Seven Pines (Fair Oaks) prior to beginning my research. To help connect the research threads I was blessed to have access to the files Bobby Krick maintains at Richmond National Battlefield Park. In addition, Jeff Stocker supplied me with several letters that he transcribed from newspapers. As the threads began connecting it became exciting as I realized the puzzle was coming together, which then fostered more enthusiasm to continue the digging.

The story behind the Battle of Fair Oaks and the struggle for the Adams House made the decision to write the story in book form an easy one.

BR: I think the easiest way to begin discussing your new book is to start with the title: “Contrasts in Command.“ Can you briefly discuss what the contrasts and commanders are at the Battle of Fair Oaks?

VV: Wow! Where to start! There are a few, but the biggest contrast is the aforementioned indecisive conduct of Joseph E. Johnston on May 31, 1862 when compared to the assertive decision making exhibited by Edwin Vose ‘Bull’ Sumner. True, Johnston’s plan was disrupted by the actions of James Longstreet; but Johnston failed to adapt to the situation. At no time on May 31 did Johnston assertively lead by personally taking charge. Simply put, Johnston failed to rise to the situation confronting him. Vigorous and assertive leadership by Johnston could have overcome the issues Longstreet created. Victory was in his grasp if he chose to seek it.

Instead, as EP Alexander, who served on Johnston’s staff during the battle, stated “his [Johnston’s] leadership was an utter failure.” Johnston’s comment to Maj. Samuel French, “I wish the troops had remained in their camps” was telling as it illustrated his docile acceptance of events. Instead of going to see where the problem existed and salvage his attack plan, Johnston remained complacent and had no intention of engaging on May 31 until stirred by a note from Longstreet urging him forward.

In contrast, Sumner was immediately motivated into action upon hearing the opening sounds of battle. Sumner saved an hour of precious time by decisively ordering his divisions to immediately assemble at their bridges. Upon receiving orders to cross the Chickahominy, Sumner crossed with his troops urging them to move quickly. He also ensured that a battery of artillery crossed the flooded river, even as it required the dragging of the guns through the mud so they would be present in battle. In contrast, Johnston brought no guns with him asserting the conditions of the roads were too poor to advance with artillery. The presence of Federal guns and the lack of Confederate guns proved decisive.

Upon his arrival at the Adams House, Sumner immediately took charge by barking out orders and positioning his defenses. He brilliantly recognized the terrain offered the opportunity for him to create an inverted salient which turned his front into a killing field. Sumner actively and visibly led from the front, which is in direct contrast to Johnston’s leadership. May 31, 1862 may have been Sumner’s best day as a commanding officer during the Civil War.

There are other contrasts as well. Longstreet’s lack luster leadership paled in comparison to the dynamic presence of D. H. Hill. A star was born through the leadership provided by Micah Jenkins. I also pitied the position encountered by William ‘Chase’ Whiting as the temporary commander of Gustavus Smith’s division. Can you imagine the difficulty he encountered while advancing into battle with Johnston riding alongside him and with Smith trailing closely behind? How much authority could he have possibly had in making command decisions?

On the Federal side Couch and John Abercrombie recognized an opportunity to escape the crisis facing them and assertively responded. Their decision to occupy the ‘slight eminence’ at the Adams House blocked the Confederate advance along the Nine Mile Road. Soon they were joined by the arrival of Sumner accompanying Willis Gorman’s Brigade. Couch, Abercrombie, and Gorman actively participated in ensuring the successful defense of the Adams House position.

I hope people now understand the significance of Fair Oaks. Johnston’s indecisive dithering when combined with Longstreet’s ineffective leadership tossed away a golden opportunity for a massive Confederate victory. It was the gritty and determined leadership exhibited by Sumner, Couch, Abercrombie, and Gorman that ended Johnston’s hopes for victory.

BR: Can you give us some context on the battle, how it fits in to the Peninsula Campaign, and why it’s important in the overall course of the war?

VV: Although indecisive, the biggest outcome of the battle of Seven Pines (Fair Oaks) lay with the division of McClellan’s army by the Chickahominy River. McClellan spent the balance of June forever promising Lincoln that victory was imminent; while also forever promising that his “arrangements for tomorrow … will leave me to strike the enemy.” Neither promise, just like his promise of “On to Richmond” ever came true.

The battle was the first major battle in the East since the July 1861 battle at Manassas (Bull Run). The growing pains evident through leadership, tactics, and poor staff work was in full view at Seven Pines. Immediately after the battle, Lee recognized the need for a reorganization of his artillery and command structures. The opposing armies each began the construction of formidable earthworks and entrenchments, the construction of which would improve steadily throughout the war.

When McClellan ceased his patient advance toward Richmond after Seven Pines, he effectively transferred the initiative to Lee, who promptly capitalized on the opportunity. Lee’s June 26 attack on Porter’s IV Corps at Beaverdam Creek opened a sequence of fighting known as the Seven Days Battles. Lee’s aggressive campaign exposed McClellan’s flaws as Lee exposed the flaws of others throughout the course of the war.

BR: What were the most surprising things you turned up during the process? Did anything conflict with or confirm your preconceived notions? What were the major stumbling blocks you had to overcome?

VV: Starting with the last part of your question first, the major stumbling blocks were the lack of earlier scholarship, Confederate accounts and accurate maps. Of the possible twenty two Confederate reports of the Fair Oaks fight, only two were submitted (Smith and Dorsey Pender). Whiting refused to write a report, informing Smith that such a report would not reflect well on Johnston, Whiting’s mentor.

With the exception of Smith’s maps, which provided a general macro view of the entire battle, the maps were all over the place. For whatever reason, the only events surrounding Fair Oaks that captured prior attention by writers was Sumner’s timely arrival and Johnston’s wounding.

The most surprising thing I turned up during my research revolved around how Johnston and Longstreet totally conspired to scapegoat Huger. Longstreet, with Johnston’s complicity, was able to establish the alleged ‘misunderstanding’ of his orders narrative while affixing blame for the failure at Seven Pines on Huger. The opportunity for Confederate victory on May 31 was massive. Only through Longstreet’s misconduct and Johnston’s leadership failure was it possible for the plan to fail. Neither man ever paid a price for their Seven Pines failure. For all the grief Longstreet bears for Gettysburg, he deserves much more for his conduct on May 31 & June 1, 1862. I defy anyone to defend it.

I kind of chuckle at the preconceived notions part of the question. I really didn’t have any because I didn’t know enough about the battle to develop notions of any kind. Remember, all I wanted to know was “where’s the Adams House?” The discovery of informational threads only improved my understanding of the fighting.

BR: Can you describe your research and writing process? What online and brick and mortar sources did you rely on most? Over the course of the years, how did technology, the easier availability of source materials like newspapers and digitized archives, change how you went about it?

VV: Not having the availability of reports and accounts meant I had to dig for the story. Again, I credit Bobby Krick for his assistance. Bobby not only helped me navigate my search but he also served as a sounding board. As I have alluded earlier, so much of what I gathered was threads from letters, newspapers and lost accounts. It took a bit of time and analysis to piece the threads together and when I did, Bobby patiently listened to my analysis, challenged it and made my analysis develop to a higher level.

There were two key discoveries that shaped my research. The first was discovering a number of Confederate accounts that mentioned crossing the muddy fields while approaching the Federal lines. But then I noticed accounts from Pettigrew’s Brigade mentioning swamp-like conditions that affected their ability to maintain their battle line. The crowning gem came from Capt. John Beall (Bell) of the 19th Georgia when he mentioned crossing “a lagoon” and how the “lagoon” forced his regiment to the right. It was then that I realized a nameless stream that appeared on all the period maps had flooded which forced a shifting of the Confederate attack to the right. That fact combined with how the 1st Minnesota formed its position by placing three companies to the front while swinging seven companies to its right in order “to provide enfilade fire down the line” that I realized the Federals couldn’t be flanked and the Confederates were in a narrow attack funnel of about 400 yards in width.

Factor in Sumner’s placement of a section of artillery on his right flank with the manner in which the rest of the artillery was deployed; and the protection of four regiments for the artillery, that I then realized Sumner had created an inverted salient. After the threads revealed the nameless stream and the inverted salient all the remaining accounts jelled. It was then just a matter of telling the story. The piecing together of the threads resulted in understanding how the attack developed and how the Confederates lost their opportunity for victory when they could/should have advanced down the Nine Mile Road at least 1-2 hours earlier than they did.

There is no doubt the accessibility of primary source materials on the internet greatly assisted my research. I found a good number of materials through the hathitrust.org and archives.org sites. I found Steven Newton’s PhD dissertation (William & Mary) on Johnston’s Defense of Richmond to be an enormous help in piecing together the challenges Johnston faced. In addition, I was blessed with discovering a good number of accounts written within the month of the fighting. The lack of previous scholarship actually assisted me since it made me focus on the quality of the threads I found.

BR: How has the book been received?

VV: I believe the book is selling well. I hope it is! I was again blessed to have received an outstanding review from Drew Wagonhoffer at the Civil War Books and Authors site. Drew also listed my book as a Top 10 book for 2023 – which pleases me and humbles me all at the same time. Call it beginner’s luck for not knowing what I don’t know but I am happy it all came together so well. Again, as happy as I am with the book, it’s a bigger achievement to have played a part in seeing the Adams property preserved by the Trust. Never again can it be said that there’s nothing to see at Seven Pines (Fair Oaks). I hope someday the Trust places a trail and wayside markers there. For sure, one can tell the story of the fight of Fair Oaks from the Adams House location.

BR: What’s next for you?

VV: I am currently researching the battle of Seven Pines, May 31, 1862. It was never my intention to follow-up with a Seven Pines book but I see there’s a need for a fresh look at the battle. I am hesitant to say this will be titled Contrasts in Command – the Battle of Seven Pines as I am still piecing the threads together. There’s a fair amount of Confederate reports and documents readily available to assist with the telling of that part of telling the story. There’s also the drama of a Federal scapegoat narrative that’s long endured as well – that being soldiers of Silas Casey’s division “fleeing by the 1,000’s!” Well, that’s what the newspapers of the day said anyway but it looks like the narrative is less than truthful. I am just starting to piece the threads I have found and I know I will find more as time goes on.





Image: Capt. Richard Thomas W. Duke, Co. B, 19th Virginia Infantry

14 11 2023
Richard Thomas W. Duke, Co. B, 19th Virginia Infantry (Wikipedia)

Richard Thomas Walker Duke at Ancestry.com

Richard Thomas Walker Duke at Fold3

Richard Thomas Walker Duke at FindAGrave

More on Richard Thomas Walker Duke

Richard Thomas Walker Duke at Cvillepedia

Richard Thomas Walker Duke at Wikipedia





17 Years Blogging

14 11 2023

That’s a long time, seventeen years. Still hanging in there. “Blogging” doesn’t adequately describe what I do here – and especially not in the preachy, editorial, demagogy, “opinions are like assholes” way the term Civil War Blog has come to be regarded in general. Hold on, am I playing the role of a pot here? Please excuse me!

It was a busy year for Bull Runnings and your host. A hearty “THANK YOU” to the Powhatan, Ft. Sumter, Rufus Barringer, Mason-Dixon, Central Ohio, Raleigh, Ohio Valley, and Western Pennsylvania Civil War Roundtables who had me in to speak in 2023. Eight talks, three different presentations, and ideas for more (like, the 6th NC at First Bull Run, for example).

Thanks to Irish in the American Civil War, who had me on their Campfire Chats series to talk about the 69th New York State Militia for what turned out to be three segments.

Thanks to Addressing Gettysburg Podcast who had me in the studio to talk about Bull Runners at the Battle of Gettysburg. Kind of a stream of consciousness thing, and we were all over the place. Names kept popping into my head while “on the air.” Chaos ensued. I believe the segment will air in early 2024. This may turn into and article and presentation, so if any roundtables are interested in that, drop me a line.

Lastly, thanks to Civil War Times magazine. I published an article in what looks like their last print issue (at least for now) after 60+ years, Summer 2023. It was fun writing I Was the First Who Fell, a look at the reactions of four Confederates to their first time in battle. This too is a candidate for a presentation, though it would be from both sides, I think.

I hope you’re all coming back each and every day to see the “new” material on the battle, be they letters, memoirs, photographs, whatever. I still have a lot to put up. Onward!





Sgt. Clement D. Fishburne, Rockbridge Artillery, On the Campaign (2)

13 11 2023

From the time of the first skirmish (AN Falling Waters) Jackson’s little army was active, marching up and down this valley south of Martinsburg several days. We came up to a place call Darkeville, no village, but the home of a man name Darke I believe. There was a good spring near and a small stream which passed eastward across meadowland which stretched out for a mile in that direction. On either side the fields were covered with fine grass and we were encamped in this place several days and nights. I well remember the beautiful nights spent there. Our Battery was nearest the Pike and by this time other troops had been brought up from some were, Harpers Ferry I believe, and other Batteries were near us but not in sight, being on the west side of the Pike in a more rolling and wooded part of the country. Other Infantry, be sides Jackson’s four Regiments had also bivouacked near his. I was a private and though Chief of Caisson , known as No 8, was not a non-commissioned officer then and had guard duty to perform. I had my tour from 12 to 2 at night. The sky was as clear and beautiful as you ever saw it. A long comet stretched many degrees across, almost directly overhead, the camp fires did not at that hour burn brightly but were kept up along the line of troops, who occupied the meadows and open fields in sight of us for more than a mile. The only sounds were made by the occasional sentinels, or the horses, or the officers, who went out to relieve the guards. There was nothing disagreeable in the aspect of the war. The duties of a sentinel in our Artillery camp was very light and simple and free from danger. We had merely to walk to walk in front or rear of our guns; or near our horses, to prevent any attempt to interfere with either and very little ground to apprehend any such attempt on the part of the enemy as the outside of the large camp was well guarded by Infantry men and the Cavalry were picketed still further out in the direction of the enemy. A sentinel with a poetic fancy could have enjoyed such a life as much as the Eastern Shepherds are supposed to have enjoyed a life under the stars while employed in watching their sheep by night.

About this time we had our first sight of Gen Joseph E. Johnston, who came down to take command of the Army. He impressed every one as a “game looking” man. He was not large but was intellectual looking, well mounted and was a superb horseman. He sat his steed like a part of the animal and there was trust about him which impressed us all with the idea that he was at home n the management of an army as well as of a horse.

One day whilst at this place we were all, infantry and artillery ordered to prepare for battle and each man was provided with a days rations. As some of the companies were uniformed in dark cloth coats, not unlike some of the uniforms of the Federal Regiments, we were all required to have white cotton strips around one arm as a sort of badge by which in the confusion of a battle we could distinguish friend from foe. Early in the morning we were called up and these strips of white cotton cloth torn in four inches wide were issued by the quartermaster Sergt and tied on our arms. We were then taken a short distance from our camp and put in line of battle near the summit of a slight range of hills , which at that point extended eastward from the Turnpike road near the place Darkesville. We were green soldiers then and were deeply impressed with the belief that Patterson was very near and approaching. We spent a day in position here. No being allowed to roam along the whole line of battle I cannot say how far it extended from personal observation, but believe it was several miles long. That part of the Valley had many inhabitants who desired to be neutrals in the war and many whose sympathies were with the Federals. No doubt this great army was duly reported to Patterson with exaggerations perhaps, at any rate we were left undisturbed by him. We all became satisfied afterwards that the grand display of preparation for a desperate general engagement was a deliberate ruse planned by Gen Johnston to try his own men and get them used to “wars alarms” as well as deter Patterson from an immediate advance. The next day or very soon thereafter we began our march back toward Winchester, which we reached in a few days after most ?? experience in the Stone road in the very hottest of July weather. There was great scarcity of water along the road which added to the discomfort. We encamped a few days before we got to Winchester and then on the extreme north east of that town we again encamped in an orchard which was enclosed with a plank fence. There were many miles of this sort of fence in sight and many rock fences. After a comfortable rest one morning we were called up unusually early an intimation of approaching danger in Dr (Captain) Pendletons morning prayer and soon had orders to have three days rations prepared. Everyone was alive and stirring. Soon a regiment of Infantry came and stacked arms and immediately began to level the plank fences near us, cutting down the posts and throwing the fences flat. This looked liked business and we were experiencing again a touch of “Wars Alarms” for infantry regiments were passing to and fro and we were in readiness all to be ordered into position.

In the afternoon however of one long July day, the 18th of July, I believe it was (1861) we were ordered into line of march and the route taken was back toward Winchester. We entered the town and came out the S. West corner of it and (as soon discovered from the Winchester boys who were in the Battery) we the road leading towards Manassas or Ashby Gap. After we had gone that route for a couple of miles, we were halted to hear read by General Jackson’s adjutant a spirited general order from General J.E. Johnston to the extent our troops under Beauregard were probably engaged in a desperate conflict and that we were expected to rush to his aid and fight for our country and all that was dear to us. The order was received with a shout and we pressed on to keep our place in the advancing army. We reached the Shenandoah River that evening about dark and crossed it, some of the men wading and others riding behind mounted friends. We crossed the mountain in the night and arrived at 2 AM at a small place called Paris. I believe in Fauquier County, near the top of the mountain on the eastern side. I was riding behind some mounted man of the company, probably Dr. John Leyburn who as surgeon had a horse along and being ahead of the guns, we got permission to occupy a bed at a house at this place and wait for the arrival of the rest of the Battery. We tried to sleep in a feather bed in a closed room and tried in vain. We rested but rested poorly. We imagined the inability to sleep was due to the fact that we had grown accustomed to sleeping on the ground and with no covering above us but the sky. That was only partially true perhaps for even now, sleeping on a feather bed in July is not easily accomplished by men who are in the habit of luxuriating on hair or shucks. When daylight came we got some breakfast and looked for our guns which were near to us and soon they were brought together, the roll was called and we marched on a few miles crossing the Manassas Gap RR at a depot called Piedmont, and went into camp at a well to do looking farm house on the side of the road leading to White Plains and Manassas Junction. This was said to be the residence of a maiden lady whose name I have forgotten. She and many other ladies present greeted us gleefully and extended the hospitality of the mansion to us, not to me precisely, for I believe I did not get any benefit from their hospitable intentions from them then to get a canteen full of milk, which some more enterprising forager then myself procured for me. We rested in the shade of the magnificent tree on beautiful grass till about dusk when the men (some of whom had strolled about to neighboring farm houses) were got together and we set out on a night march. I did not know the country and do not know it know, but the “Plains” was the name of the place we stopped and in that or some other village the company rested in the street for a couple of hours just before daybreak and men slept on porches, boxes pavement etc., and it was hard to get them some of them from their resting places, uncomfortable as they were, when the signal was given to resume the march. We proceeded however till about sunrise when we stopped to feed the horses, and got some rest again. We continued the march till 3 or 4 o’clock Pm when we halted at Manassas Station on the Orange and Alex R. Road. Here was all the desolation with which we afterward became familiar, such as is marks a place where soldiers have been encamped and where they get supplies. We had been parched with heat, chocked with dust and were thirsty as well as hungry and found only one well of water and that was guarded by a sentinel whose orders prevented our getting any part of it. Our Captain had gone to get instructions as to future movements and here we lay in the sun and filth waiting for more than hour, perhaps two hours, to see what next was to happen to us. At last the orders came and we set out, riding in the carriages, ?? which was a relief, to find our camp which had been assigned to us as part of Gen Jackson’s Brigade.

After a rough ride, across fields, we got to Bull Run and the neighborhood of the infantry of the Brigade who had already gone into camp and rested, as they had gone from Piedmont on the cars. As soon as the guns halted I lay on the ground and slept as I never had slept before, sound as a rock. I was aroused up to get some supper and my mess mates and bed mates, were kind enough to let me share in the results of their labors without reproaching me from my neglect of duties. After a hearty meal, the nature of which I do not recall, I fell into my sleeping place under the trees, not far from the creek, which had two days before been the scene of the Battle of Bull Run, the 18th July fight, and again slept the most unconscious sleep that ever fell to the lot of man. I heard nothing and dreamed nothing till the sun was well up, when I was roused by the stir of the camp and soon heard the report of a 30 pounder which was said to be near Centerville and which was fired at random in our direction. Captain Pendleton had also slept hard or had been so considerate as to not rouse us up at his usual hour for morning prayers. The camp was soon fully roused, for there was no toilet making to take up time and after one of the Captain’s alarming prayers, we got breakfast, and under orders, filled our haversacks with a days rations. In the course of an hour we had orders to hitch up and form into column of march and wait for orders. We were in a hollow or ravine running down to the creek and not far from the latter, perhaps fifty feet. We were formed with head of column up the ravine, southward and whilst there saw groups of men and officers, and some of our own men joined them, on an open hill to the front and left of our own column. They seemed to be watching with interest some movements of the enemy north of the Creek (Bulls Run) in the direction of Centerville. Presently a report from a big gun which had first roused us was heard and there was a commotion on the hill as a shot passed near the hill top. Another soon followed and that passed over the creek and struck the ground not many yards to the left and front of our first gun. Then Captain Pendleton marched us up the ravine and to the right under cover of and around the piece of woods in which we had encamped and proceeding and proceed southward finally halted us after going a mile or more near a well traveled road which appeared to run east and west, parallel with Bull Run.

The dust on the road was deep and the sun was fearfully hot. We went to the edge of the road in a small field, not over a hundred yards from the road and here we waited. The country here abouts is rolling but has no very elevated points from which we could make out what was going on outside the woods which bounded our vision westward. We could see great clouds of dust and could distinguish the fact that a fight was in progress west of us several miles in which artillery and musketry were freely used. We then began to realize that we would be probably engaged in a bloody battle, but it is impossible for me to describe my sensations. I certainly did not long for a part in the fray but was resigned to obey orders and hope for a bloodless encounter. How long we had been standing near the Bull Run and marching to the our present resting place and how long we had rested here I do not now recall, but at last there was the clatter of horse feet and the clashing of armor which announced the passage along this road from the east of a group of officers and mounted men. They halted opposite to us and voice called out inquiring what artillery this was. Captain Pendleton approached and answered the inquiry and was ordered in somewhat peremptory tone, I thought to advance along the road which would be pointed out by a courier. The cavalcade of officers who consisted as we learned afterwards of Gen J.E. Johnston and other Generals and their staff officers and couriers and dashed off in the direction of the firing and we all mounted limber chests and caissons and advanced at our best speed in the same direction. We went a mile or more before we saw any unmistakable signs of battle. Then we began to see men straggling back who said the battle was going on hotly and many intimidated that all was lost. Presently we met wounded men who called for us to hurry on, some badly wounded were being helped back by comrades and it struck us that the wound and their comrades were less despondent than the sound men whom we met. Some of the suffers called out words of encouragement. Our rapid motion and the frequent running conversations with these men whom we met kept us from any grave reflections on the dangers into which we were venturing. At last we halted in the road not far from the “Lewis” House to wait from some definite orders as to where we should go. While here we saw the Staunton Artillery, Captain Jno D Imboden, slowly drawing back, badly crippled as we all then thought. Having some acquaintances in the company, Will Nelson and T. Waddell and others, we got some information as to what had been done. From their account of it we learned that this battery had been engaged and had lost some horses and some men wounded, perhaps had left a piece of artillery on the field, but of that I am uncertain. At any rate the men were not demoralized and on the whole we were encouraged to hope at least that we might fight and yet live to fight another day without having to run away. They were simply falling back under orders and did not know what would be their next orders, whether to form in another part of the line or not. Before many minutes delay were piloted to the left down a wagon road through a pine and stunted oak thicket and up again from a small branch to the hill on the crest of which we finally unlimbered and commenced the work of the day. As we went through the woods rising towards the final fight ground, the shell and Minnie balls from the enemy made a terrible racket over our heads and near us, and we passed one of the Washington College boys who belonged to the 4th VA infantry in our brigade, taking care of a wounded comrade who afterwards passed??, a youth well known to many of our company. He and many others had been wounded while lying on the ground near the top of the hill awaiting orders.

We reached the top of the hill and turned to our right in an old field and unlimbered our guns and commenced firing to the left of the direction in which we entered the field. Just in the rear of the Battery we found the infantry lying on the ground. The Colonels and field officers at the head of each and Jackson riding backwards and forwards in front of them. When we approached he gave orders where each gun should take position, just in front of his infantry, except one gun which was sent a little to the right of his line. Im not much of draftsman but on the opposite page I give a rough outline of our position, and of the Henry House (AN not present on microfilm). There was a stunted growth in front of us down the hill and part of the way up the opposite hill, on which was located the Henry House and near this house were trees, an orchard I believe. The enemy artillery was near it and they were firing rapidly shells, which sounded horribly as they passed over our heads. In front of us somewhere, perhaps in the shelter of the brush were the Federal Infantry, who Minnie balls, kept a racket about our ears that was worse than mosquitoes. The only human way of accounting for our not having been knocked to pieces before we got into position and directly afterwards is that the enemy’s artillery was fired too high. The Minnie balls missed us because we occupied a very little of the space through which they passed and because kind providence sent them into unoccupied spaces.

I do not recall the fact that I was frightened badly, but do recall the fact that I wished it was all over and I was well out of it. I was fortunately employed, as the orders were to use ammunition in the caissons first and leave the limber chests untouched. Our guns were four in number and the gun I was with was the howitzer. Next on the left was the 6 pounder brass gun at which Liv Massie was No. 1. One other gun was so far to the left of us that a gun of another battery came in between it and our fourth gun was some distance to our right. At the usual regulation distance in rear of each gun was its limber chest and about 14 feet in the rear of that were the heads of the horses of the caissons. All the horsed heads were turned to the front. Some anxiety had been expressed lest we would have difficulty in holding the horses, which we assumed would be scared and give us trouble. Men were assigned to duty to aid the drivers if necessary. To our surprise the horses seemed to be perfectly indifferent to the danger and the only trouble was to keep them from getting tangled in harness in their effort to eat the scanty grass at their feet.

I was chief of caisson and had to give out ammunition to the men who were detailed to carry it to the gun. Our caisson chests had been made in Winchester and were mounted on the running gear of common country wagon, so that I could not stand on the ground and get out their contents. I had to be helped up and sat on the edge and in this position I reached out the ammunition and handed it to the men who carried it. Whilst occupying this perch I confess that I had too much time to consider the situation and remember distinctly wondering if it would be unsoldier like in me to dodge these Minnie balls which were flitting by my ears or to bow when those horrid shells passed over me. I saw Capt. Pendleton who had just been commissioned Colonel make a motion like dodging and thought there could be no harm in it, but I saw Gen Jackson while riding along his beat was often not fifty steps in rear of me, sitting on horse which had been shot in the thigh, with his chin cocked up as if he was expecting a rain and was not adverse to having a drop of it on his face. He had his hand raised wrapped in a handkerchief and was evidently wounded, but he refused to dodge. I do not know whether I tried to imitate him or not, but I shall say that I bowed involuntarily more then once. I learned by the way that, afterwards that dodging was not inconsistent with the highest courage and was quite allowable provided a fellow did not lose his wits and conclude to get out of danger before his orders came to do so.

One Minnie ball was kept from me by the lid of the chest out of which I was getting ammunition and whilst I was in the act of handing a shell to Smith (Rev J.P. Smith afterwards on Jackson’s Staff) over the wheel of the caisson, a ball struck the wheel and glanced and hit him on the forearm. He felt it severely of course and I saw it drop to the ground at his feet and pointed it out to him. He put it in his pocket and hurried to the gun with the shell. He found that afterwards that the ball which had been flattened on the wheel had made a broad blue bruise on his arm and had stiffened considerably.

During the progress of the fight I had to dismount and assist one of the drivers, Bob Lewis, to detach one of the horses which had been struck by a Minnie on the upper part of the hoof. When we got him out we found he could still walk and we put him back again. I remember also that I regretted that I was not alongside Liv Massie whom I could see working vigorously at his gun. He seemed to be very busy and as cool as if he was playing baseball, which is not a cool play however. His excitement seemed to be gratifying to him. From where I was on duty I could not well see the position of the enemy, but when I got down to fix the horse, I took a peep and learned the position of the enemy’s artillery. The practice which we had in the Valley in estimating distance enabled our gunners to know very how far off was their target and as it was very nearly at point blank range for our guns, we rarely missed doing good execution every time. We afterwards found that Col Ricketts battery with which we were engaged was a splendidly equipped Battery in US service, the same which had won glory in Mexico, six 10 pounder parrot guns with six horses to each gun and each caisson and that our guns aided by a few guns of another battery had knocked it into a heap. The horses and men were piled together and not force enough left to take them off the field. The range was too short for these rifled guns and the gunners in all probability did not know it.

During the progress of the battle I saw a caisson which was on line with mine and about fifty steps to the left (east) explode. The explosion being caused by a one of the enemy’s shells which had been better aimed than the rest. I saw the chest fly up and there was a huge blaze and much commotion. Some of the men had their shirts burnt, they were in their shirt sleeves, and were themselves scorched a little but not seriously. There was some commotion with the horses but it was soon quieted and the dreadful work went on. This caisson belonged to a Richmond Battery which had been put into position immediately to the left of the gun that Massie was at and between that gun and our extreme left hand gun.

At last the order was given to “limber up” and to say that it was not a welcome sound to most of us would be scarcely true. I certainly was pleased to hear the order, but could not tell whether it meant that we would advance or fall back. Immediately however and whilst we were executing this order the infantry in our rear was called up from their recumbent posture and fell rapidly into line by regiments. I knew the field officers of the 4th Va Regt, which was nearest to me and heard them their orders and just as we were moving out toward our right, this regiment advanced over the ground we had occupied at a double quick and went out of sight with a yell down the hill in the direction of the Henry House. We went slowly out from the line which we had occupied and as soon as the guns were all brought together, we slowly made our way down the hill by a line parallel with that along which we had gone up and made our way out of the woods to the cleared ground nearest to and west of the Lewis House. Here we halted and the men and officers tumbled to the ground, waiting for orders and wondering what we had done and what next we would have to do. Whilst there we were making conjectures as to how long we had been engaged. Some said 15 minutes some said an hour. I and many others thought we had been engaged about 30 minutes. Lieut Wm McLaughlin (afterwards Capt and Col of Artillery) who had started us at these conjectures settled the question. He had looked at his watch when the first order was given to commence firing and found it to be 2 o’clock. When the order to was given to cease fire firing it was 4 ½ o’clock. We had been at work then two hours and half and whilst it was by no means pleasant work to any of us, time flew rapidly.

We lolled here for some time listening to the sounds of battle which seemed to go westward, leading us to hope that the enemy was giving way and that our troops were pursuing. Soon these hopes were sustained by rumor and from our position after a while we could at a distance and north westwardly from us see indications of a disorderly retreat along the road toward Centreville on the north side of Bulls Run not far from the Stone Bridge which was a prominent feature in the accounts of the battle given afterwards by both sides. A battery some hundreds of yards west of us, which had also been engaged and had been withdrawn as ours had been to await orders was posted and one of the guns ran forward to a point of the hill and opened on the mass which we saw moving northward from the Bridge. Soon a few shots were fired from a gun or guns on the north side of Bulls Run in reply to this gun from our neighboring Battery and a solid shot took off the head of one its Lieutenants, a Lieut. Macon of Richmond. That was the only damage done and the firing from the north side ceased and I suppose the battery from which they came ceased to exist as a battery. We were so near when this sad death occurred that no little gloom was cast over us. It was like a death by violence in cold blood. Macon was merely like we were, looking at the retreat and watching with interest the effect of the firing from the only gun of his battery that was then engaged.

Before sun down we were assured the infantry of our Brigade had dashed forward with other troops and had driven the enemy from the ground near the Henry House and had pursued them till they were exhausted, in the direction of the main road leading to Centreville. Some of our men got permission to go back to the battle field and they returned to us loaded with canteens, haversacks, well filled with “hard tack” and oil cloth and woolen blankets. Others went with a horse or two and came back supplied with many luxuries which we had never known. Among the plunder brought to us were large tarpaulins used to cover the guns and caissons of the celebrated Rickett Battery which we had knocked into uselessness.

We went into camp very near the Lewis House and had our supper for the most part from the haversacks of the enemy. We slept as usual in the open air, for we had no tents and had none up to that time and about 2 o’clock in the morning were waked by the rain which seemed to be coming very gently but steadily. I crawled under one of the captured tarpaulins which was lying near and slept till morning. When we were roused a more forlorn and miserable looking set of men were never seen. Some of us were thoroughly wet, all more or less muddy, the horses wet, the camp equipage wet and dirty and no fires were lighted and what was worse no fuel was prepared with which to kindle fires. The day before had been clear and hot and the fatigue and excitement had prevented any provision for a rainy day. We had not examined the water supply or the wood supply and here we were all drenched and without breakfast. The horses had first to be cared for and how this was done I had no personal knowledge, but it was done some how. Cooking had to be done and the men went to the neighboring fences, where any were left and got rails or to the woods which were not far off and got together fuel. Then came the difficulty about water. We found that the well at the Lewis house was protected by a sentinel in as much as that house had been converted during the night into a hospital. We tried to catch water from the roof of the house, but to our disgust found that part of it flowed from the roof of a long back porch and that on that roof the limbs which had been cut off from wounded soldiers in the upper rooms had been thrown. We were afraid to use the water from the streams which were then flowing freely at the foot of every hillock, because we did not know but that this water flowed from some field hospital or washed the spot where some poor fellow had shed his life blood. I don’t remember exactly how we finally got our breakfast or what we had for breakfast, certainly we had no ?? dishes. The great absorbing questions now were how has this command fared, what loses, did this friend escape and so on. This was the first battle and Regiments and companies were not so well organized as they afterwards became and there was much straggling. Men did not, event those who had done their duty, fully know where to find their headquarters. Many of them did not rejoin their commands for several days and tidings of them could not be got. This was less true for the artillery men for they had to stay with their guns and horses and these staid together and were a rallying point. None of men were missing and very few were hurt. The wounds of these were not very serious. Lieut. Brockenbrough was slightly wounded in the foot and got a furlough, Smith was wounded by a spent ball as I have described and I think Sergt Jordan was slightly wounded. As many of our men of our men were from Rockbridge Co. Va, they were anxious to know the result of the battle and the damage done to the Rockbridge infantry companies, two of which were in the 4th Va. I had several friends and acquaintances in that Reg and in the 5th Va, which were the Augusta County companies.

During that day we were called on to bury young Davidson, a private in a Rockbridge Infantry company and brother of the Greenlie Davidson whom we all knew well. He had been wounded in the stomach and was carried into an out house in rear of the Lewis House and very near our battery. He wound had been mortal and when I saw him he was dead. We had nothing to dig a grave with our battery not being supplied with spades as batteries usually are, but we got axes, staves and such things as we could and made a grave wherein we laid him enshrouded in the old blanket on which he was lying and coffined with barrel stave which we laid over his body. It was a sad scene, this rainy, dreary day after the victory, a band of soldiers some of them personally unknown to the poor fellow, laying away his body in this ignoble grave.

Many of the brave young fellows who had entered the army with the belief that we would be victorious heroes after a six month war, ended their lives on this bloody field. This battle, called the Battle of Manassas was fought on the 21sst of July 1861. Subsequently, in 1862 another battle was fought on nearly the same ground called the 2nd Manassas Battle, in August 1862, in which the relative positions of the two armies on the field were reversed. The confederates were victorious in both and Stonewall Jackson was a prominent figure in each. I was not at 2nd Manassas.

We spent the 22 and 23 of July miserably in the mud and rain near the Lewis House and about the 24th or perhaps the 25th we removed and went into camp a few miles distant, but I cannot exactly recall where it was. My father visited me whilst at this camp, having gone down to for himself how it faced with me and with my brother, Elly whose Regt, the 1st Va Cavalry under Col Stuart had done service on the retreat of the enemy towards Washington. I walked over part of the Battlefield with Father and the scenes we witnessed did not encourage us to stay long or to make a very thorough examination. Many of the dead had been overlooked by the burial corps and the stench from the dead horses was dreadful. There was a remarkable absence of birds of prey about the field of Battle.

Clement Fisburne Memoir – Rockbridge Artillery – University of VA Acc No. 2341 (pg A-Z of Notebook 1 and pgs 1-17 of Notebook 2.) No date was given but it was likely around the time that the “Historical Sketch of the Rockbridge Artillery.” Southern Historical Society Papers, 23 (1895), was written as portions of both text match somewhat.

Contributed and transcribed by John Hennessy

Clement Daniels Fishburne at Ancestry.com

Clement Daniels Fishburne at Fold3

Clement Daniels Fishburne at FindAGrave

Clement Daniels Fishburne at Cvillepedia





Interview: Styple, “General Philip Kearny: A Very God of War”

12 11 2023

William B. Styple has worn many hats: researcher, author, speaker, publisher, and reenactor. Many of you may have encountered him in the Gettysburg NMP’s Visitor Center bookstore over the years, peddling his wares and tales. In 2022 he published his so-far life’s work, General Philip Kearny: A Very God of War. Bill recently took some time to discuss the new book.

——————–

BR: Can you tell us a little bit about yourself?

WBS: I have been a student of the Civil War since the 1960s, and actively writing since the 1980s. I co-wrote the video documentary series, Echoes of the Blue & Gray with the late Brian Pohanka; the documentary depicts Civil War veterans recorded on motion-picture film during the 1890s-1950s. I can honestly say that Brian Pohanka was my earliest influence, and he is greatly missed. Before Brian passed away in 2005, he was consulting on my book: Generals in Bronze, Interviewing the Commanders of the Civil War. That volume contained over 50 previously unknown interviews made by artist James E. Kelly (1855-1933) with Generals Grant, Sherman, Sheridan, Hancock, Hooker, Webb, Warren, Sickles, to name a few. In their book review, Civil War Times Illustrated called Generals in Bronze “a blockbuster History of the Civil War.” And it certainly was: the Kelly interviews have forever changed the history the Civil War.

I also published three volumes of letters written by the common soldier, both Union and Confederate; all totaling about a thousand letters documenting the history of the war as told from the front lines—the collection is called Writing & Fighting the Civil War.

Another important discovery I made in 2012 was the unpublished writings of Colonel Thomas M. Key, who served as General George B. McClellan’s “Confidential Aide” and “Political Adviser.” General McClellan’s posthumously published memoir was called, McClellan’s Own Story; and so in turn I called my book McClellan’s Other Story, The Political Intrigue of Colonel Thomas M. Key. Here is a documented story from the Civil War that McClellan and his supporters do not want you to read. A never-before-told history that contains many astounding revelations—which sometimes tends to upset some of those so-called Civil War experts. Apparently, discovering the unpublished letters of Colonel Key did hurt some egos; but I do not apologize. (See his Amazon Author Page here.)

BR: What got you interested in the Civil War?

WBS: I was raised in the small town of Kearny, New Jersey, founded in 1867, and named after its most famous resident killed in the Civil War. My family home was not far from where Philip Kearny built his gothic-style mansion—known to us townsfolk as Kearny Castle. Also standing nearby was the New Jersey Home for Disabled Soldiers & Sailors, a care facility for those Union veterans who had borne the battle. From 1887-1932, some 20,000 Civil War veterans resided in my neighborhood, living out their final years at the Old Soldiers’ Home; those toddling, blue-clad, octogenarians were beloved members of our community, and it was a common sight for passersby to see the old veterans sitting under shade trees, telling a group of wide-eyed youngsters remembrances of Bull Run, Antietam, and Gettysburg, along with memories of President Lincoln and, of course, legendary stories of the fiery One-Armed Devil—Phil Kearny.

Those recollections told to the eager young listeners in my hometown were later passed down to me; so naturally, the Civil War and Phil Kearny became a life-long passion, and for over 50 years, I’ve collected anything relating to General Kearny: his personal military equipage, his correspondence, books from his library, artwork from his private collection, furniture from his domicile, and other trivial effects. I literally started writing the Kearny biography decades ago; it has been my full time occupation since the 1980s. The book contains one million words, and a thousand footnotes, 880 total pages.

BR: We’ve never seen a biography of Kearny of this depth (or length). In a nutshell, what does your book contribute to the literature that has not already been contributed?

WBS: The two prior biographies of Philip Kearny were written by family: Cousin John Watts De Peyster wrote the first in 1869; and Grandson Thomas Kearny, wrote another in 1937. Both of those biographies are unreadable—full of nonsense—and they do not tell the whole story of Phil Kearny. Another book was published in the 1960s, mainly for children, which contains lots of silly, invented, dialogue. Unfortunately, modern-day writers/historians source these three books, which only propagated the erroneous myth of Philip Kearny. In fact, most writers of books/articles continue to spell Kearny’s name incorrectly—so if you are reading a battle history and the author spells General Kearny’s name: KEARNEY, they really don’t know anything about Phil Kearny. And I can say with certainty: I have never read a Kearny-related article published in the various Civil War magazines since the 1960s, which are not full of errors.

My biography of Philip Kearny tells the whole story of his life, both personal and military, both positive and negative. John Watts De Peyster chose not tell of Kearny’s life scandals, and Thomas Kearny may have touched upon those scandals somewhat, but did not tell the whole story. My book contains the entire story—the whole truth—describing one of the greatest scandals of the 1850s (until Dan Sickles shot Philip Barton Key); Philip Kearny was divorced from his first wife in 1858 and the procedure records were ordered sealed for 100 years. I was the first to untie the red tape and learn the whole truth—spicy details which historians and even Kearny’s own descendants were entirely unaware of.

BR: Give us the skinny on Kearny. Can you sum him up in a paragraph or two that will make folks want to read more?

WBS: I’m afraid it’s impossible to sum up Phil Kearny in a single paragraph—just as it’s equally impossible to present a one-hour lecture on his life (he died at age 47). Phil Kearny was a born soldier, who fought in five wars—fighting in Africa, Mexico, the West, Italy, and the Civil War. In every battle, in each war, he rode straight into the enemy lines and fought his way out. It cost him an arm in Mexico, his life at Chantilly. He was the first American soldier to receive the Legion of Honor from France.

At the onset of the Civil War, Phil Kearny was the most combat-experienced soldier—he had seen more war on a grand scale than any general, north or south, with the possible exception of Winfield Scott—who called Kearny: “The bravest man I ever knew, and a perfect soldier.” And that’s coming from the top, folks. In fact, Lee, Grant, Longstreet, all the antebellum army officers, considered Kearny to be the most gallant and “perfect soldier.” During the Civil War, Kearny was a non-West Pointer, who came to the rescue of several West Pointers (Federals) on numerous battlefields. He literally saved the Army of the Potomac from disaster at Williamsburg, Seven Pines, and Glendale. Kearny’s role in the Second Battle of Bull Run has been misrepresented by a legion of jealous commanders, and in my book, I explain how and why.

The bullet that killed Kearny at Chantilly/Ox Hill, and the note his wife Agnes wrote upon the envelope in which it was sent to her (Courtesy W. B. Styple)

BR: Your book has been in the works a long time. Can you describe how long it took, what the stumbling blocks were, what you discovered along the way that surprised you or went against the grain, what firmed up what you already knew? When did you know you were “done?”

WBS: I started learning about Phil Kearny in 1967; his portrait hung in my elementary school classroom, alongside portraits of Washington and Lincoln; the more I learned about Kearny, the more I wanted to learn. But, it wasn’t till the late 1980s when I commenced serious research on Kearny’s life. I decided early on to make this biography totally unique. Of the thousands of Civil War biographies written since 1865, no one has done one like this. I had to know where Kearny was every week of his life, and every detail of the five wars he fought in. Some of his earlier life was difficult to piece together, but I believe I have accomplished what I set out to do. There were several important discoveries made along the way, as I have mentioned before, the Kelly interviews, Colonel Key’s letters, etc.

After writing the chapter covering the details of Kearny’s death at Chantilly, I still wasn’t finished; there are four more chapters covering the days, weeks, months, decades after Kearny’s demise.

BR: Can you describe your research and writing process? What online and brick and mortar sources did you rely on most? Over the course of these many years, how did technology, the easier availability of source materials like newspapers and digitized archives, change how you went about it?

WBS: I made countless trips to the National Archives to research Kearny and everyone connected to him militarily; also the New Jersey Historical Society, the Library of Congress, and libraries scattered throughout the United States, and France. Digitized newspapers were a great help over the past ten or so years, much easier than the old microfilm rolls which I used in the 1980s and 90s. General Kearny commanded about 20 regiments; and each regiment was raised in a hometown—scattered in Michigan, Maine, New York, Pennsylvania, New Jersey; and I would comb through those hometown newspapers for soldier-letters describing Kearny in camp and battle; the result was I found hundreds of important battle descriptions written by Kearny’s soldiers, within hours/days of the fight; the best source material.

BR: How has the book been received?

WBS: Most folks are very pleased with my work and research, especially the newly-discovered letters/battle accounts. I’ve learned that if you can present something new to the students of the Civil War—something they haven’t read before, they are very gratified. My favorite comment was: “Thank you for not writing about Grant or Lee.”

BR: What’s next for you?

WBS: I am currently working on an updated/revised edition of Generals in Bronze for 2024, which will contain about 40 additional pages of previously unpublished accounts of the Battle of Gettysburg and other Civil War events; also, never-before-told stories of Grant, Lee, Lincoln, and others. To be sure, this will be another blockbuster-history of the Civil War. I guarantee it.





Image: Pvt. William Nathaniel Wood, Co. A, 19th Virginia Infantry

10 11 2023
William Nathaniel Wood, Co. A, 19th Virginia (Source)

William Nathaniel Wood at Ancestry.com

William Nathaniel Wood at Fold3

William Nathaniel Wood at FindAGrave

More on William Nathaniel Wood

Nathaniel Wood memoir, Reminiscences of Big I





Sgt. Henry S. Shanklin, Co. D, 27th Virginia Infantry, On the Battle

9 11 2023

Manassas Junction
July 23rd 1861.

My dear Parents

With a bleeding heart do I write this morning Monday 23 attempt to write you these few lines we were engaged in a tremendous battle yesterday and we have to mourn the loss of of several of the Monroe Guards. Capt. Tiffany was killed immediately we marched on the field he was shot in the right brest he survived but a short time he died galently the last time I saw him he was in front of his company urging them on his last words were [this line illegible] God bless his soul & strengthen her to receive this dreadful news. Col. Prestons regt* & ours marched to the field at the same time & we had to lay flat down upon the ground for a long time, two hours I suppose we were right behind our batterys. The Canon Balls Bombs & bullets flying over our heads thick and fast one shot exploded in front of us and kill several of Prestons men three of our boys killed & one wounded with it they were Arch Campbell Mr. O Camp & John Conner killed John C. Lynch wounded & Wiley Wingfield was shot thro with a ball he lived several hours afterwards Col Prestons regt was ordered to charge soon afterwards, our companys was seperated as soon as we got up from the ground Our regiment made a dreadful charge said to be the most effective charge that was made We put them to flight, but suffered greatly Wm Jennings planted our flag on their cannon he received two flesh wounds not dangerous. Poor Bob Hamilton was instantly killed he fought bravely he leaves many mourning friends. Charley Tiffany was wounded in both legs they are flesh wounds, one of them in left thigh. Charley Shanklin in the head, I have not seen him yet.

David Shanklin was shot between the shoulders I dont think he will get well. Patrick Cavanagh wound slightly Leut Wiley wounded in the same

Lieut Zoll by a spent ball on the shoulder a ball [hit] William Patton in the hand I have not seem him Greenvill Rutlidge rcvd a slight wound I dont know where John Fry slight wound in the head Cadet Wight our drill master was wounded in the head not dangerous, he is a fine fellow. The battle was a dreadful one such as never was seen by mortal man. It is reported that there was fifty thousand of the enemy and we did not have more than two or three regiments engaged against them at one time we repulsed them three or four times, thousands of the enemy was killed & wounded and a great many taken prisners. Our loss was considerable but nothing like the number of the enemy. We captured two of Shermans famous battery The flag of the Monroe Guards waved over them there was thirteen pieces of that battery taken wagons a glorious victory thank God Stuarts cavalry numbering from 1500 to 2000 men followed [them] 6 miles I did not get the least scratch thanks to my God. I fought until I was ordered back I fired seven rounds. I dont know whether I killed anyone or not. I fired in the same group all the time they were not more than 100 yds off Well I am compelled to do my chore – – – dead to bury I am going to the battlefield directly I will give full particulars of our march from Winchester here at the battlefield I am in hopes this will stop the fight for a while we are at the loss to know what to do for another captain we will never have another one like the one we had. God bless his soul. pray for me continually God saved me yesterday he will save me at last you need write until you hear from me again

Your devoted son Henry

Capt. Steel & Lewis Caperton has this morning com to our camp

MS #25688 Va. State Library, Richmond, Va.

Source image

Contributed by John Hennessy

*4th Virginia Infantry

Henry S. Shanklin at Ancestry.com

Henry S. Shanklin at Fold3

Henry S. Shanklin at FindAGrave?